10551 Pleasant Valley Road
Parma, OH 44130
The moment you walk through the doors of Rito’s Bakery in Parma, you can smell all of the delicious, fresh baked goods. This family-owned and operated business has been a part of the Cleveland food scene since 1964. The cookies are made from authentic Sicilian recipes that the bakery’s founder, Santo Rito, has used for almost 50 years. At Rito’s, you will find Kolachies, coconut macaroons, snowballs, Italian almond cookies, lemon cookies, sugar cookies and so much more. You can even order online so no matter where you are in the country, you can still have the delicious cookies from Rito’s.
2681 West 14th St.
Cleveland, OH 44113
This Tremont-based pastry shop is the place to go if you are looking for custom designed cookies. The owners have been working together since 2003, and in 2008 they decided to open up their own bakery. The ladies at A Cookie and a Cupcake make amazing homemade sweets and are always striving to give their customers exactly what they want. A Cookie and a Cupcake even offers vegan and gluten-free options. Even if you aren’t looking for a custom designed cookie, still stop in to grab yourself a yummy classic cookie or sugar cookie.
12101 Mayfield Road
Cleveland, OH 44106
Located on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, Presti’s Bakery sells cookies individually, by the pound or by the tray. In May of 2014, Vice President Joe Biden made a stop at Presti’s for some baked goodies. If you are looking for a large selection, Presti’s is where you will want to go. This bakery has a wide array of cookies to choose from including Thumbprints, Pignolis, Butter Balls and chocolate chip. During the Christmas season, even more speciality cookies are added to the menu.
Related: Best Hot Desserts In Cleveland
49 West Orange St., Suite 5
Chagrin Falls, OH 44022
When making cookies, Sugar Me Desserterie uses the finest natural ingredients around and will also use local ingredients when available. The scrumptious collection of cookies at Sugar Me will make your taste buds happy. Some cookies that you will find here include sugar lime cookies, oatmeal trail mix cookies, ginger cookies and Mexican wedding cookies. If you are in the market for custom cookies for a wedding, shower, birthday or other special event, Sugar Me Desserterie will create just what you are looking for.
4261 Mayfield Road
South Euclid, OH 44121
Cookies created by Christine Zadnik-Mehling, owner of Better Bit of Butter Cookies, taste like a bit of heaven while looking like a piece of art. Each of the cookies is made from scratch with all-natural butter and local, cage-free eggs. They also contain no preservatives and zero trans fats. Better Bit of Butter Cookies will make custom designed cookies for any occasion, large or small. You can meet with the owner to create a unique design or choose from a pre-exsisting design.
Related: Best Ice Cream Sundaes In Cleveland